Although there may not be direct studies on bad cat behavior and its link to humans there are relevant research areas that can be linked to the idea of using cats with bad behavior as a form of behavioral intervention or psychological correction for those who need it.
The Psychological Benefits of “Restorative Stress” and Stressor Exposure
Study: "The Role of Acute Stress in Improving Performance and Psychological Resilience"
by L. K. Latham, et al. (2015).
Summary:
This research examines the concept of “restorative stress” — the idea that exposure to mild, controlled stressors can improve personal resilience and help individuals process negative emotions. While prolonged or extreme stress is harmful, short bursts of irritation or frustration (when controlled) can lead to improved emotional regulation, self-reflection, and even personal growth. The study suggests that experiencing mild irritants, such as interruptions or challenges that require patience, can actually help individuals who struggle with impulse control or negative behaviors.
The Impact of Negative Reinforcement on Behavior Modification
Study: "Reinforcement and Behavior Change: The Role of Positive and Negative Reinforcement in Human Behavior" by J.A.
Durlauf (2001).
Summary:
This research explores how both positive and negative reinforcement influence human behavior. Negative reinforcement, when applied effectively, can lead to behavior modification by introducing discomfort or irritation that encourages individuals to alter their actions. The study suggests that people who habitually irritate or annoy others might become more aware of their own behavior if they experience mild but consistent consequences — in this case, the intentional irritation caused by a cat's bad behavior.
The "Payback" or "Karma" Effect: How Retributive Justice Alters Behavior
Study: "When is Payback Sweet? The Role of Anticipatory and Retributive Justice in the Regulation of Aggressive Behavior" by J. E. Carlsmith, et al. (2008).
Summary:
This study investigates how the concept of retributive justice — the idea that individuals who cause harm or irritation should experience some form of proportional retaliation — can influence behavior. The research suggests that people who experience retribution for their bad actions (even mild forms of it) are more likely to modify their behavior. This concept ties into the idea of “karma,” where people feel they should “get what’s coming to them” if they’ve been disruptive or unpleasant. The study highlights how experiencing a consequence (such as a disruptive cat) might encourage people to rethink their actions and become more self-aware.
